New shades, same pout-ential.
Make Up For Ever’s bestselling Artist Color pencils are creamy, long-wearing, versatile — and just got an upgrade. This week, the brand dropped 10 new colors, including shimmery “cosmic” versions of stars’ favorites, like Wherever Walnut and Anywhere Caffeine, along with pretty new matte options.
Made for use on eyes, cheeks or lips, the cult-favorite liners have garnered famous devotees, including Hailey Bieber, Sofia Richie Grainge, Jennifer Lopez and Sabrina Carpenter — not to mention thousands of brand fans.
Bieber, Lopez and Richie Grainge all use the original Anywhere Caffeine, and the new shimmer version is set to become a bestseller.
Stars often use the pencil to line their lips, before applying a shiny balm or gloss for a multi-dimensional pout that looks plump and hydrated. With the new cosmic shimmer shades, you can also apply the color to both eyes and lips for a gorgeous monochromatic look.
There’s also a new cool, pinky-nude shade, Wherever Walnut Light, that’s a paler variation of the longstanding favorite that Bieber also wears, along with Olympian Suni Lee.
The new Cosmic Wherever Walnut sold out immediately at Sephora, but you can still grab it on the brand’s website with free shipping on purchases over $29.
We’re adding a $7 pencil sharpener to our carts as well, to preserve our new babes (and get that free shipping).
The art-inspired pencils are so versatile that you may even want to grab a few. Shoppers rave about the multi-use product as well, leaving feedback like, “I buy this pencil on repeat. It’s the only lip liner I use.”
A second shopper wrote, “It does not move, and it’s so pigmented. It is literally so smooth and glides on just like it should!”
Additional new shimmer-free colors include Total Taupe — a definitive 90’s throwback shade that’s also lovely for eyes — Pumpkin Spice, a terracotta color, and Dreamy Pink, a warm rose. Plus, for something deeper, we’re also crushing on the berry-hued Dramatic Plum.
We tried Cosmic Limitless Brown on eyes and lips, and the warm, subtly sparkly effect is just so pretty.
Grab yours while you can, before they sell out!
Why Trust Page Six Style Shopping
This article was written by Erica Radol, Page Six Commerce Reporter. From identifying the top anti-aging skincare secrets the stars trust to dishing on the latest fashion collabs to finding a great deal on all of the above, Erica has a knack for reporting on – and even testing – Hollywood’s bestselling fashion and beauty products. Before joining Page Six in 2025, she wrote about entertainment, lifestyle and shopping trends for Us Weekly, The Daily Beast, Entertainment Tonight, Well+Good and Hearst.
Read the full article here
