January 19, 2026 7:27 pm EST

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig may be following their exes down the aisle.

Multiple sources tell Page Six the couple, who started dating in 2023 after their exes got together, have been telling friends they’re getting married.

“It’s very serious,” one source said.

“They’re not rushing it. They’ve both been married before. It is something they’re thinking about,,” they added.

Shue and Fiebig’s relationship was the ultimate plot twist in their exes, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes’ scandal.

After the office romance between “GMA 3” co-hosts Roback and Holmes became the most sensational story to hit broadcast news since Matt Lauer’s “Today” firing, Page Six exclusively reported Shue and Fiebig had struck up a relationship of their own. Sources at the time told us their exes’ scandal brought them closer.

The couple previously had a “long-time [social] friendship” due to Holmes and Robach’s work relationship at “GMA,” according to sources. “They’d all hang out here and there, but [Fiebeg and Shue] weren’t that close,” a source told us when they first started dating.

Nearly a year after their exes sparked up their romance, Shue and Fiebeg’s relationship blossomed. The two even moved in together last year.

One source familiar with the couples quipped “maybe it was all meant to be,” suggesting that Shue and Fiebeg makes more sense than Shue and Robach – and vice versa.

“Amy and T.J., they’re out there. You want the party, that’s them. Andrew’s a lot more chill. They all seem like they’ve found their partner, ironically,” they said.

Meanwhile, they reportedly made Robach and Holmes’ wedding invite list, according to Us Weekly, which noted they’re “not expecting” to them come. (Sources told us it’s all a little premature, since there’s not even a wedding date yet.)

And while all are happily in love on both sides, they’re “not going on double dates,” another source said.

The couple did not get back to us.

Read the full article here

Share.
Leave A Reply

Exit mobile version